Pie Shop Hours



Order Ahead

We bake to order all week long!
Please place your order 48 hours in advance. Amanda's Bakery


    There are no dates yet.

Pie Club

On the second Sunday of each month (or Wednesday or Friday, if you have a farmers market membership!), your Pie Club selection will be waiting for you, along with a special Pie Club member treat. It may be some of our handmade candies, cookies, or a surprise from a kitchen experiment! Once you’ve picked it up, we’ll post it here so everyone who hasn’t joined Pie Club yet can turn green with envy.


Triple Citrus Meringue: (lemon, lime and pink grapefruit) in a flaky pastry crust


Elvis pie: luscious banana cream filling in a bacon & peanut butter crumb crust,
topped with peanut butter whipped cream


Samoa: just like the cookie! Shortbread crust, sweet & salty caramel, ganache and toasted coconut


Ricotta: our freshly made ricotta*, sweetened and spiced with nutmeg & citrus zest


Rhubarb: a puckery tart and sweet pie made with rhubarb from our own patch


Strawberry Lemonade: a buttery lattice top crust, bursting full of fresh strawberries and lemon zest


Big Berry: all of the local berries we can get our hands on!


Bourbon Peach: gorgeous local peaches bathed in bourbon, ginger, & a sprinkle of sea salt


Candy Apple: a caramel apple pie filling in our classic crust, drizzled in candy apple coating


Pumpkin Praline: our classic pumpkin spice topped with crunchy pecan praline


Apple Cider Cream Pie: flaky, buttery crust filled with apple cider custard


Gingerbread Pie: a delightful molasses and spice pie in a butter crust

* we use milk from Brush Hill Dairy


Whether you’re heading to a Solstice gathering or hosting Christmas at your house, there’s lots of celebrating going on this month! We’ve got you covered in the desserts department.

Please place your order via email: order@luckygirlbakery.com, or by calling 860 770-1563.
You are also welcome to send us an order via Facebook message: Facebook.com/LuckyGirlBakery

Please arrange pick up date when ordering. For Christmas Eve pick-up, orders must be placed by December 20th. For New Years Eve pick up, orders must be placed by December 26th.
All other orders, please give at least 48 hours notice.


Tea Time Bundt ~ chocolate earl grey cake dusted with confectioner’s sugar
(serves 12-16)  $28

Stout Gingerbread ~ our favorite super-moist, richly spiced gingerbread!
(serves 12-16) $28

Buche de Noel ~ amazingly light flourless chocolate cake with your choice of either mint or vanilla filling, draped in ganache and festively decorated!
(serves 10-14) $42

Apple Gingerbread ~ Upside down gingerbread with brown sugared apples Retail Store Supplies
(serves 8-10) $19


Chocolate Candy Cane ~ chocolate crumb crust with minty ganache and white chocolate & crushed candy cane garnish $16

Classic Apple ~ warmly spiced apples in our classic, double crust $17

Cranberry Mince ~ cranberries, raisins, dates, citrus & spices in our classic crust  &16

Cinnamon Custard ~ rich cinnamon custard in our flaky (all butter!) pie crust $16 discount shoes online

Chocolate Bourbon Pecan ~ a Lucky Girl classic, loved all year round! $18


Assorted Springerle Cookies ~ beautiful classic designs. Choose sugar or gingerbread cookies
per dozen/$14

Classic New England Hermits ~ rich molasses, spices and raisins Vacuum Sealer Reviews.
per dozen/$14

Spicy Hot Cocoa Mix ~ make a rich warm mug of cocoa!
6oz bag $5

Handmade Marshmallows ~ choose from vanilla, candy cane, or bourbon
per dozen/$6